| NOTE:
The following NTSB excerpts of accidents related to the Pitot
System occurred while not using PitotShields. PitotShields are specifically
designed to disengage during flight, and tests show that PitotShields
disengagement can and does occur during takeoff. Each of the the following
NTSB reports involve pitot covers, when used at all, that are not
PitotShields. |
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: BFO94FA091 . The docket is stored in the (offline)
NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Tuesday, June 07, 1994 at EDGARTOWN, MA
Aircraft:MOONEY M20J, registration:
N4393H
Injuries: 1 Fatal.
ACCORDING TO THE AIRPORT MANAGER, HE DID NOT WITNESS THE PILOT'S
PREFLIGHT OF THE AIRPLANE. HE STATED THAT THE PILOT DEPARTED
RUNWAY 24 IN A NORMAL MANNER AS HE DID ON MANY OCCASIONS.
HE STATED THAT HE WAS UNABLE TO SEE THE AIRPLANE INITIALLY
DUE TO THE LOW VISIBILITY. HE SAID IT WAS 1/2 MILE IN FOG.
HE STATED THAT HE SAW THE AIRPLANE IN A DESCENDING RIGHT HAND
SPIRAL. THE AIRPLANE IMPACTED THE GROUND ABOUT 300 FEET SOUTHWEST
OF RUNWAY 21 AND WAS DESTROYED BY FIRE. THE AIRPLANE WAS EXAMINED
AT THE ACCIDENT SITE. THE EXAMINATION
REVEALED THAT THE PITOT TUBE COVER WAS IN PLACE ON THE PITOT
TUBE.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
THE PILOT'S INADEQUATE PREFLIGHT INSPECTION THAT
FAILED TO REMOVE THE PITOT TUBE COVER WHICH LED TO LOSS OF
CONTROL OF THE AIRCRAFT.
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: NYC84LA257 . The docket is stored on NTSB
microfiche number 26933.
Nonscheduled 14 CFRPart 135 operation of Air Taxi & Commuter
PANARAMA FLIGHT SERVICE, INC.
Accident occurred Saturday, July 28, 1984 at WATERVILLE, ME
Aircraft:GATES LEAR JET 25B,
registration: N1JR
Injuries: 2 Serious, 3 Minor.
DURING PREFLIGHT PREPARATION FOR DEPARTURE
FROM A SHORT FIELD THE PLT FAILED TO REMOVE THE PITOT TUBE
COVERS. ON TAKEOFF ROLL, THE STALL WARNING LIGHT BEGAN
TO FLICKER. PLT NOTED AIRSPEED WAS NOT REGISTERING BUT DID
NOT CONSIDER THIS UNUSUAL IN THE EARLY PART OF A TAKEOFF ROLL.
PLT TURNED LEFT STALL WARNING SWITCH OFF, THEN BACK ON, WARNING
LIGHT REMAINED ON. PLT THEN INITIATED ABORT PROCEDURES, USING
FULL REVERSE THRUST AND BRAKES. THE ACFT OVERRAN RUNWAY BY
ABOUT 100 FT AND DOWN A ROUGH EMBANKMENT WHICH SEPARATED THE
LANDING GEAR.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
AIRCRAFT PREFLIGHT..INADEQUATE..PILOT
IN COMMAND
REMEDIAL ACTION..DELAYED..PILOT IN COMMAND
Contributing
Factors
TERRAIN CONDITION..DOWNHILL
TERRAIN CONDITION..ROUGH/UNEVEN
AIRSPEED INDICATOR..DISREGARDED..PILOT IN COMMAND
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: NYC00FA001 . The docket is stored in the
(offline) NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Saturday, October 02, 1999 at CALDWELL,
NJ
Aircraft:Cessna 401B, registration:
N88VA
Injuries: 3 Serious, 5 Minor.
The pilot aborted the takeoff run after the airspeed indication
rose to about 80 miles per hour, but would not go any higher.
He could not stop the airplane, before it went off the end
of the runway, over a berm, and into a drainage ravine.
When the airplane was pulled out of the ravine, both pitot
covers were still in place, around the pitot tubes. The
runway was 4,553 feet long, calculated takeoff distance
was about 2,525 feet, and calculated accelerate-stop distance
was approximately 2,950 feet. Tire skid marks started around
3,600 feet from the approach end of the runway, and led
to the wreckage. About a year earlier, another airplane
was destroyed when it ran into the same ravine, which was
located about 200 feet from the end of the runway.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the
probable cause(s) of this accident as follows.
The pilot's inadequate preflight,
which resulted in an attempted takeoff with the pitot covers
installed. An additional cause was the pilot's delayed
decision to abort the takeoff, while factors included the
misleading airspeed indications, and the proximity of the
drainage ravine to the end of the runway.
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: LAX94LA109 . The docket is stored in the (offline)
NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Sunday, January 30, 1994 at WATSONVILLE,
CA
Aircraft:CESSNA 182, registration:
N21106
Injuries: 2 Uninjured.
THE PILOT FAILED TO REMOVE THE PITOT TUBE COVER BEFORE DEPARTING
ON THE DARK NIGHT ACCIDENT FLIGHT. THE PILOT NOTICED THAT
THE AIRSPEED WAS NOT REGISTERING UNTIL THE AIRPLANE WAS NEAR
THE END OF THE RUNWAY. TIRE SKID MARKS BEGAN 1,042 FEET BEFORE
THE END OF THE RUNWAY. THE AIRPLANE EXITED THE RUNWAY AND
THE NOSE GEAR COLLAPSED WHEN IT ENTERED THE SOFT CLAY TERRAIN.
THE AIRPLANE NOSED OVER ONTO ITS BACK.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
THE PILOT'S INADEQUATE PREFLIGHT INSPECTION
BY FAILING TO REMOVE THE PITOT TUBE COVER AND DELAY
IN HIS REMEDIAL ACTION BY NOT BEGINNING TO STOP THE AIRPLANE
UNTIL IT WAS ABOUT 1,000 FEET BEFORE THE END OF THE RUNWAY.
THE SOFT TERRAIN AND THE COLLAPSED NOSE LANDING GEAR ARE FACTORS
IN THIS ACCIDENT.
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: BFO87LA040 . The docket is stored on NTSB
microfiche number 35034.
Accident occurred Saturday, May 30, 1987 at FREDERICKSBURG,
VA
Aircraft:CESSNA 152, registration:
N25448
Injuries: 2 Uninjured.
THE CFI STATED THAT DRG TKOF, THE ACFT ACCELERATED SLOWER
THAN NORMAL. AFTER ROLLING ABT 1800', THE STUDENT ROTATED
THE ACFT TO A NORMAL CLIMB ATTITUDE & IT CLIMBED APRX
5' TO 10'. AT ABOUT THAT TIME, THE CFI NOTED THAT THE AIRSPEED
INDCN HAD DROPPED TO ABT 40 KTS & THE ACFT BEGAN TO DSCND.
HE THEN TOOK THE CONTROLS & ABORTED THE TKOF WITH ABOUT
700' TO 800' OF RWY REMAINING. HE APPLIED BRAKES, BUT THE
ACFT SKIDDED OFF THE RGT SIDE OF THE RWY AT THE DEP END &
HIT A CONCRETE PAD CONTAINING RWY END/THRESHOLD LIGHTS. THE
TEMP WAS 90 DEG & THE DENSITY ALT WAS APRX 2250'. THE
CFI EXPECTEDA LONGER THAN NORMAL TKOF ROLL, BUT AT THE TIME
OF THE OCCURRENCE, HE COULD NOT UNDERSTAND WHY THE INDCD AIRSPEED
HAD DROPPED. RPRTDLY, THE OWNER HAD
INSTALLED A MOVABLE COVER ON THE PITOT TUBE TO KEEP INSECTS
OUT, WHICH COULD BLOCK ITS OPENING DRG HI ANGLE OF ATTACK
OPNS.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
FLIGHT/NAV INSTRUMENTS,AIRSPEED INDICATOR..FALSE INDICATION
MAINTENANCE,MODIFICATION..IMPROPER..COMPANY/OPERATOR
MANAGEMENT
ABORTED TAKEOFF..DELAYED..PILOT IN COMMAND(CFI)
Contributing
Factors
WEATHER CONDITION..HIGH DENSITY ALTITUDE
OBJECT..RUNWAY LIGHT
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: FTW97LA200 . The docket is stored in the (offline)
NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Friday, May 23, 1997 at SPRING, TX
Aircraft:Beech BE-56TC, registration: N7890R
Injuries: 1 Uninjured.
Immediately after takeoff, the pilot informed the control
tower that he was going to return to land. While landing,
the left wing of the airplane struck the runway. He stated
that a loose dog distracted him during the preflight as he
had to close a hangar door to prevent the dog from entering.
During takeoff roll, the engine instruments appeared normal,
except for the airspeed indicator, which indicated 'sixty'
knots. He continued down the 7,000 foot runway, and lifted
off with the airspeed indicator still indicating about 'sixty'.
After lift off, the pilot knew something was wrong and told
the tower he was going to make a right turn to downwind and
return for landing. After landing, the pilot noticed that
the left wing and left propeller were damaged and that the
pitot tube cover was still installed on the pitot tube. The
estimated takeoff weight of the aircraft was about 5,100 pounds.
The manufacturer's published airspeed for lift off at 5,500
pounds gross weight is 89 knots. The measured cloud cover
(ceiling) at the time of the accident was 100 feet overcast
with 1 mile visibility
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
The pilot's failure to perform an
adequate preflight (did not remove pitot tube protective covering
prior to flight) which resulted in an inaccurate cockpit
airspeed indication during takeoff roll and subsequent emergency
landing. Factors were, the pilot's diverted attention while
performing his preflight (loose animal on the ramp), the pilot's
failure to abort the takeoff after noticing an airspeed anomaly
during takeoff roll, and the low ceiling (100 feet overcast)
the pilot encountered after lift off and while returning to
land.
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: ATL87LA205 . The docket is stored on NTSB
microfiche number 34315.
Accident occurred Wednesday, July 08, 1987 at GULF SHORES,
AL
Aircraft:PIPER PA-28-181, registration:
N8389Y
Injuries: 3 Uninjured.
THE PLT ABORTED THE TAKEOFF ABOUT HALF WAY DOWN THE 3600 FT
RWY AFTER OBSERVING THAT THE AIRSPEED INDICATOR WAS INOP.
BEFORE HE COULD STOP THE ACFT, IT RAN OFF THE END OF THE RWY
& WENT INTO A DITCH. AN EXAM BY AN A&P MECHANIC REVEALED
THAT THE PITOT HEAD WAS OBSTRUCTED
BY A MUD DAUBER NEST. THE OBSTRUCTION WAS NOT VISIBLE
THRU THE PITOT OPENING. THE MECHANIC NOTED THAT THIS TYPE
OF PROBLEM WAS COMMON AT THAT ARPT. THE ACFT HAD BEEN FLOWN
SVRL DAYS BEFORE THE ACDNT WITH NO PROBLEMS. THE PLT OPERATING
HANDBOOK RECOMMENDED THAT A PITOT COVER BE USED WHENEVER THE
ACFT WAS NOT IN USE.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
ABORTED TAKEOFF..DELAYED..PILOT IN COMMAND
Contributing
Factors
PITOT/STATIC SYSTEM..BLOCKED(TOTAL)
TERRAIN CONDITION..DITCH
AIRCRAFT PROTECTIVE COVERING..NOT
USED..COMPANY/OPERATOR MANAGEMENT
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: FTW83LA269 . The docket is stored on NTSB
microfiche number 23066.
Accident occurred Tuesday, June 07, 1983 at SAN ANTONIO, TX
Aircraft:BEECH 95-B55, registration:
N1757W
Injuries: 2 Uninjured.
WHILE
ON THE TAKEOFF ROLL, WITH APRX 1400 FT OF RWY REMAINING, THE
PLT NOTICED THAT THERE WAS NO INDICATION OF AIRSPEED. HE THEREFORE
ELECTED TO ABORT THE TAKEOFF, THE RWY WAS A COMBINATION OF
ASPHALT & TURF. FOLLOWING HIS DECISION TO ABORT, THE REMAINING
PORTION OF THE RWY WAS TURF, STILL DAMP FROM THE MORNING DEW.
HE WAS UNABLE TO STOP ON THE REMAINING RWY. AFTER OVERRUNNING
THE RWY, THE ACFT HIT AN IRRIGATION DITCH & NOSED OVER.
A POST- ACCIDENT EXAM REVEALED INSECT
LARVAE IMBEDDED IN THE PITOT TUBE, ABOUT 1/8 INCH FROM
THE TUBE'S END. ACCORDING TO THE PLT, THE ACFT HAD BEEN PARKED
OUTSIDE & HAD NOT BEEN FLOWN FOR APRX 70 DAYS PRIOR TO
THE ACCIDENT FLT. HE FURTHER RELATED THAT HE NOTICED NOTHING
ABNORMAL ABOUT THE PITOT SYS DURING HIS PREFLT INSPECTION.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
PITOT/STATIC SYSTEM..FOREIGN OBJECT
AIRCRAFT PREFLIGHT..INADEQUATE..PILOT IN COMMAND
FLIGHT/NAV INSTRUMENTS,AIRSPEED INDICATOR..INOPERATIVE
ABORTED TAKEOFF..DELAYED..PILOT IN COMMAND
Contributing
Factors
TERRAIN CONDITION..DITCH
AIRPORT FACILITIES,RUNWAY/LANDING AREA CONDITION..WET
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: NYC94LA121 . The docket is stored in the
(offline) NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Tuesday, July 12, 1994 at WHITE PLAINS,
NY
Aircraft:PIPER PA-60-700P,
registration: N323CB
Injuries: 1 Minor, 4 Uninjured.
DURING AN ABORTED TAKEOFF, THE AIRPLANE OVERRAN THE 4451
FOOT LONG RUNWAY, WENT DOWN A HILL, AND STRUCK A FENCE.
ACCORDING TO THE PILOT, 'DURING THE TAKEOFF ROLL, THE INDICATED
AIRSPEED NEEDLE CLIMBED TO APPROXIMATELY 60 KNOTS, BUT THEN
WOULD GO NO FURTHER...MY ATTEMPTS TO DISLODGE IT BY TAPPING
ON THE FACE OF THE GAUGE WERE FUTILE...I PULLED BACK THE
THROTTLES AND APPLIED FULL BRAKES...' THE PILOT REPORTED
THAT BASED ON THE EXISTING CONDITIONS 'THE AIRPLANE CAN
ACCELERATE FROM REST TO ROTATION SPEED AND BACK TO REST
IN LESS THAN 3500 FEET.' THE EXAMINATION OF THE AIRPLANE
REVEALED THE PITOT TUBE WAS INTERNALLY
OBSTRUCTED WITH AN INSECT AND MUD.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the
probable cause(s) of this accident as follows.
The pilot's delay in aborting the takeoff.
A factor was internal obstruction of the pitot tube.
|
|
EXCERPTS
FROM NTSB REPORTS-PITOT SYSTEM
NTSB
Identification: LAX93FA095 . The docket is stored on NTSB
microfiche number 50309.
Accident occurred Friday, January 15, 1993 at RENO, NV
Aircraft:CESSNA 414, registration:
N4733G
Injuries: 2 Fatal.
A CESSNA 414 COLLIDED WITH A LEVEL GROUND WHILE ATTEMPTING
TO LAND DURING A SNOW SHOWER. THE PILOT REPORTED AN EMERGENCY
ONE MINUTE AFTER DEPARTING IFR AND REQUESTED TO RETURN TO
THE AIRPORT UNDER VISUAL RULES. THE PILOT INDICATED TO AIR
TRAFFIC CONTROL THAT 'I CAN'T GET ANY SPEED.' THE VISIBILITY
WAS VARIABLE AROUND THE AIRPORT WITH THE LOWEST REPORT OF
1/2 MILE. WITNESSES OBSERVED THE AIRPLANE TRAVELING FAST AT
LOW ALTITUDE AND INDICATED BOTH ENGINES WERE RUNNING. INVESTIGATION
REVEALED DURING SERVICING BEFORE THE FLIGHT, THE PITOT TUBE
COVERS WERE NOT USED. ABOUT 1.5 INCHES OF SNOW HAD ACCUMULATED
ON THE AIRPLANE DURING THE REFUELING AND WAS BRUSHED OFF.
THE AIRPLANE WAS SEEN FLYING INTO A SNOW SHOWER AND REVERSING
COURSE. WITNESSES REPORTED THE AIRPLANE'S ANGLE OF BANK TO
BE 80 TO 90 DEGREES WITH A 20 DEGREE PITCH DOWN ATTITUDE.
THE AIRPLANE DESCENDED INTO A SNOW COVERED PASTURE. WITNESSES
REPORTED THE AIRPLANE LEVELED ITS WING JUST BEFORE IMPACT.
MANUFACTURER'S SAFETY AND WARNING SUPPLEMENTS INDICATE INFLIGHT
ICE PROTECTION IS NOT DESIGNED TO REMOVE SNOW ON PARKED AIRCRAFT.
THE MANUFACTURER RECOMMENDS USE OF HEATED HANGARS OR APPROVED
DEICING SOLUTIONS TO INSURE THE ARE NO INTERNAL ACCUMULATIONS
IN PITOT STATIC SYSTEM PORTS.
The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable
cause(s) of this accident as follows.
THE FAILURE OF THE PILOT TO USE PITOT
STATIC SYSTEM COVERS DURING ICING CONDITIONS WHICH
RESULTED IN A BLOCKED PITOT TUBE AND SUBSEQUENT LOSS OF AIRSPEED
INDICATIONS. THIS LED TO PILOT DISORIENTATION AND AN INADVERTANT
STALL. FACTORS TO THE ACCIDENT WERE IMPROPER SNOW REMOVAL
AND ADVERSE WEATHER CONDITIONS.
|
|
|
|
| DeGroff
Aviation Technologies 2002 |
|
|